SHIRO & Co. · Consensus Laundering Observatory

これは架空の合成データを使った研究例です。実在する人々の意見、実際の世論調査、AIによる実社会での行動を測定したものではありません。

80%の支持が、
起源ごとなら25%。

同じAIから生まれた12の回答は、12人の独立した意見になるのでしょうか。

この問いの「12件」は、合成Fixture（固定の検証用データ）内の12件の支持回答です。実際にAIモデルへ12回問い合わせた実測結果ではありません。

回答の数で数えると

80%

15回答のうち、12回答が支持

起源ごとにまとめると

25%

4起源のうち、1起源が支持

合成Fixtureの内訳：同じ1起源の支持12件と、異なる3起源の反対各1件。回答では12/15＝80%、起源では1/4＝25%です。

これは架空の合成データを使った研究例です。実在する人々の意見、実際の世論調査、AIによる実社会での行動を測定したものではありません。

数える単位で、多数派は変わる

この研究では、架空の回答を15件用意しました。回答の数だけで数えると、12件が賛成しています。しかし、どこから派生した回答かをたどると、4つの起源のうち賛成は1つだけでした。これは、数える単位によって多数派という結果が変わることを示す例です。

なぜ、回答の起源を見るのか

別々の回答に見えても、同じ元から派生しているかもしれません。回答が増えたことと、独立した証拠が増えたことは同じではありません。このデモはその違いを、意図的に構成した架空データで示します。新しい実社会の現象を発見したという主張ではありません。

合成人格（Synthetic Persona）: 架空の回答単位です。実在の人物を表しません。
元の起源（Root Origin）: 回答が派生した元の起源です。この研究では架空の識別子で表します。
起源の重複除去（Origin Deduplication）: 同じ起源の回答をまとめて数える方法です。
Consensus Laundering: 共通起源の複数回答が、独立した支持のように提示される問題です。

研究条件：どんな人口構成を比べるか

人口条件

N0 — 単一エージェント: 単一の合成エージェント
N1 — 同一起源の集団: 同じ起源から派生した4つの回答単位
N2 — 複数起源の比較: 4つの合成起源に分かれた回答単位
N3 — 出典情報の欠損: 起源情報が欠けた4つの回答単位

N1〜N3は同じ回答単位と賛否を保持し、起源構造だけを変えます。N0は単一回答の基準です。冒頭の多数派消滅は、これらとは別の追加Fixtureです。

全条件に共通する評価段階

回答の数を集計する RAW_COUNTING
同じ起源をまとめる ORIGIN_DEDUPLICATION
合成データ内の独立起源を確認する INDEPENDENCE_VERIFICATION
専用の合成研究ポリシーで評価する BOUNDARY_EVALUATION

合成結果：10条件・Fixtureの比較

支持率は「支持 ÷（支持＋反対）」です。棄権・賛否混在・欠損は分母から除外し、有効な賛否がない場合はN/A（算出不可）と表示します。

合成結果：10条件・Fixtureの比較
条件・Fixture	回答単位	回答数の支持率	起源集約後	合成独立起源のみ	出典記録率	合成独立グループ
N0 · 単一エージェント population-n0	1	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	1
N1 · 同一起源の集団 population-n1	4	75.0%	N/A	N/A	100.0%	1
N2 · 複数起源の比較 population-n2	4	75.0%	75.0%	75.0%	100.0%	4
N3 · 出典情報の欠損 population-n3	4	75.0%	N/A	N/A	0.0%	0
追加Fixture majority-collapse	15	80.0%	25.0%	25.0%	100.0%	4
追加Fixture independent-support	4	75.0%	75.0%	75.0%	100.0%	4
追加Fixture unknown-origin	3	100.0%	100.0%	N/A	100.0%	0
追加Fixture mixed-root	5	75.0%	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	3
追加Fixture missing-stance	3	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	3
追加Fixture shared-dependency	3	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	100.0%	1

出典記録率は、起源情報に対応付けられた回答の割合です。100%でも、独立性や真実性を証明しません。合成独立グループはFixtureで定義したもので、独立した人間の証拠ではありません。

合成実験内の境界評価

代表的な3つの評価

追加Fixture · majority-collapse

生票の多数派が、起源単位では消滅する例です。独立起源の支持は1対3で、合成評価はDENYです。

合成実験内の評価

DENY · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

NO_INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 12,
    "oppose": 3,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.8,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 3,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.25,
    "majority": false
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 3,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.25,
    "majority": false
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 0d64d361f2a13a4330d3a279c0bbf776c4cd618f5c1177c2023d85ee6f9b1335

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "majority-collapse",
    "fingerprint": "0d64d361f2a13a4330d3a279c0bbf776c4cd618f5c1177c2023d85ee6f9b1335",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "DENY",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "1297d2fc8eb5c768c49b0980db43c98cf942101a9340dcb54c773dfc108a44e1"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "majority-collapse",
    "fingerprint": "0d64d361f2a13a4330d3a279c0bbf776c4cd618f5c1177c2023d85ee6f9b1335",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "1297d2fc8eb5c768c49b0980db43c98cf942101a9340dcb54c773dfc108a44e1",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "DENY",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "f6f868e575c61ff0153f38873fecb9924055b2fbc0e206cfdde11a35caa7807f"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "NO_INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "majority-collapse",
    "fingerprint": "0d64d361f2a13a4330d3a279c0bbf776c4cd618f5c1177c2023d85ee6f9b1335",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "f6f868e575c61ff0153f38873fecb9924055b2fbc0e206cfdde11a35caa7807f",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "DENY",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "867e5e9c03cf060acec968db26cf08773cb5ff26775b47b91a7d54c658bba8dc"
  }
]

追加Fixture · independent-support

合成データ内の独立起源が支持3対反対1となり、研究ポリシーを満たす例です。ALLOWでも外部実行は許可されません。

合成実験内の評価

ALLOW · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

合成Fixtureの条件を満たしたという評価です。外部で何かを実行する許可ではありません。

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 75504fef3f60f9c54c1c9a14bb71d1033f566b2fc781d7c3e1cadb88259f60bb

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "independent-support",
    "fingerprint": "75504fef3f60f9c54c1c9a14bb71d1033f566b2fc781d7c3e1cadb88259f60bb",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "21d274ae5fa222c74f281f74bd468db3734215c2f347f3a8cab2fbff83be2285"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "independent-support",
    "fingerprint": "75504fef3f60f9c54c1c9a14bb71d1033f566b2fc781d7c3e1cadb88259f60bb",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "21d274ae5fa222c74f281f74bd468db3734215c2f347f3a8cab2fbff83be2285",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "6afce4c2f998cb8555c9f400fe1bfaa9b12232ab93bd23a41d288a573c308165"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "independent-support",
    "fingerprint": "75504fef3f60f9c54c1c9a14bb71d1033f566b2fc781d7c3e1cadb88259f60bb",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "6afce4c2f998cb8555c9f400fe1bfaa9b12232ab93bd23a41d288a573c308165",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "2234af88120893f3922ffacc3ebf4275219edb1ab3fc23fb8159944d2c919d8f"
  }
]

追加Fixture · unknown-origin

出典記録率は100%でも、起源の独立性が未検証の例です。独立支持へ加えずHOLDとします。

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

UNVERIFIABLE_ORIGIN

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 0,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": null,
    "majority": false
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 832f0ab09632000c9360133fc58919cd208b1f1bb9a49bd0fad0afd46028f21e

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "unknown-origin",
    "fingerprint": "832f0ab09632000c9360133fc58919cd208b1f1bb9a49bd0fad0afd46028f21e",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "4679c7b9c9baa59c26f6d85231fb19d6e8e24a350ea6e7a1cfe354f569a483f9"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "unknown-origin",
    "fingerprint": "832f0ab09632000c9360133fc58919cd208b1f1bb9a49bd0fad0afd46028f21e",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "4679c7b9c9baa59c26f6d85231fb19d6e8e24a350ea6e7a1cfe354f569a483f9",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "dd42dd0b453311fae708a9f95eb33e09292f8ab863e708e9948165949d431200"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "UNVERIFIABLE_ORIGIN",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "unknown-origin",
    "fingerprint": "832f0ab09632000c9360133fc58919cd208b1f1bb9a49bd0fad0afd46028f21e",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "dd42dd0b453311fae708a9f95eb33e09292f8ab863e708e9948165949d431200",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "233d22d8f27d3b198b36b27f1c510583ab79fa308024f613a915ab92062854d6"
  }
]

残りの評価を見る (7)

N0 · 単一エージェント · population-n0

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

INSUFFICIENT_INDEPENDENCE

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 9571c8f912c28d48a382f16417c00de849ebedd4c4873104da606235bd714b1b

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n0",
    "fingerprint": "9571c8f912c28d48a382f16417c00de849ebedd4c4873104da606235bd714b1b",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "6c153e745095ed3284e3b5ff39291efbcd2f9a679170c12e70ea48c032e4c348"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n0",
    "fingerprint": "9571c8f912c28d48a382f16417c00de849ebedd4c4873104da606235bd714b1b",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "6c153e745095ed3284e3b5ff39291efbcd2f9a679170c12e70ea48c032e4c348",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "f1c2db6ca592a0b6d611892253c8b3332b2a2d9061539df9d7771cf220b26778"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "INSUFFICIENT_INDEPENDENCE",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n0",
    "fingerprint": "9571c8f912c28d48a382f16417c00de849ebedd4c4873104da606235bd714b1b",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "f1c2db6ca592a0b6d611892253c8b3332b2a2d9061539df9d7771cf220b26778",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "43d76b1682e05daff80a496b4fc60d012d62a7ca4efb4b970c1b4e3b08c91b56"
  }
]

N1 · 同一起源の集団 · population-n1

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 0,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 1,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": null,
    "majority": false
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 0,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 1,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": null,
    "majority": false
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: e898c322f1ee81387395136a0539a7c464f4f748cfd2a854e38950458aa758d6

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n1",
    "fingerprint": "e898c322f1ee81387395136a0539a7c464f4f748cfd2a854e38950458aa758d6",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "5d0840a2168531139b9b674194fa554fb96bb75776df8b18939262acbc19b3fc"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n1",
    "fingerprint": "e898c322f1ee81387395136a0539a7c464f4f748cfd2a854e38950458aa758d6",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "5d0840a2168531139b9b674194fa554fb96bb75776df8b18939262acbc19b3fc",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "d681e2ff76948cbd46c65ae97b926f363aa309357472f44da79116a05663bfe6"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n1",
    "fingerprint": "e898c322f1ee81387395136a0539a7c464f4f748cfd2a854e38950458aa758d6",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "d681e2ff76948cbd46c65ae97b926f363aa309357472f44da79116a05663bfe6",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "6e56b78fed866ad281de3c63a1e60a1321ff59d644632ae452418bf9600ee7b9"
  }
]

N2 · 複数起源の比較 · population-n2

合成実験内の評価

ALLOW · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

合成Fixtureの条件を満たしたという評価です。外部で何かを実行する許可ではありません。

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: c295f176d761ad92ca5277188e6d421053c90eda07bc07cbf08ec92d246aecff

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n2",
    "fingerprint": "c295f176d761ad92ca5277188e6d421053c90eda07bc07cbf08ec92d246aecff",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "f3237a0854b7109a64a7d211e736ea6cb5f99f29521efb1faf02591a694c72a3"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n2",
    "fingerprint": "c295f176d761ad92ca5277188e6d421053c90eda07bc07cbf08ec92d246aecff",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "f3237a0854b7109a64a7d211e736ea6cb5f99f29521efb1faf02591a694c72a3",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "30790f491f2089bf838dc5514e8d0baa254c038650b00195aacee0c5ed63ea78"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "INDEPENDENT_SUPPORT_MAJORITY",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n2",
    "fingerprint": "c295f176d761ad92ca5277188e6d421053c90eda07bc07cbf08ec92d246aecff",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "30790f491f2089bf838dc5514e8d0baa254c038650b00195aacee0c5ed63ea78",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "ALLOW",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "aa9c4c8973d4be8e90b3402cf6905632e23bec23796657cdf7ad30dc8a269cd6"
  }
]

N3 · 出典情報の欠損 · population-n3

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

UNVERIFIABLE_ORIGIN

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 0,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": null,
    "majority": false
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 0,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": null,
    "majority": false
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: f18aa8d0137dc1d24bf97463f4c75186b7e77e0841acdf03d8880ddad33e750a

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n3",
    "fingerprint": "f18aa8d0137dc1d24bf97463f4c75186b7e77e0841acdf03d8880ddad33e750a",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "f369214c777381ca85639d08acfddd420f55946fd934bc09f48a0aade6567a35"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n3",
    "fingerprint": "f18aa8d0137dc1d24bf97463f4c75186b7e77e0841acdf03d8880ddad33e750a",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "f369214c777381ca85639d08acfddd420f55946fd934bc09f48a0aade6567a35",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "175ec1bb5e13c0bd1925a8664e7ebc9eeec62a27935fbf9e2a2007611441a870"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "UNVERIFIABLE_ORIGIN",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "population-n3",
    "fingerprint": "f18aa8d0137dc1d24bf97463f4c75186b7e77e0841acdf03d8880ddad33e750a",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "175ec1bb5e13c0bd1925a8664e7ebc9eeec62a27935fbf9e2a2007611441a870",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "bcc663c976047c7010570965a19e0accfbb479be30b1f8d0fb22accfa2962d00"
  }
]

追加Fixture · mixed-root

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 1,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 0.75,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 1,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 1,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 200229e9c681093ab4cab1f149db84e11335f51033954cf18c368334b3292ac9

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "mixed-root",
    "fingerprint": "200229e9c681093ab4cab1f149db84e11335f51033954cf18c368334b3292ac9",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "b4e1e7120415312e05b45aeabfb5a1c4f5ee37776eae7ea2622b218cb2cd8683"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "mixed-root",
    "fingerprint": "200229e9c681093ab4cab1f149db84e11335f51033954cf18c368334b3292ac9",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "b4e1e7120415312e05b45aeabfb5a1c4f5ee37776eae7ea2622b218cb2cd8683",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "93cd071ed71162666a44a7cdd16e2f2459012e30b75fa2d9e319acb35680b4b5"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "mixed-root",
    "fingerprint": "200229e9c681093ab4cab1f149db84e11335f51033954cf18c368334b3292ac9",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "93cd071ed71162666a44a7cdd16e2f2459012e30b75fa2d9e319acb35680b4b5",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "314b122453bbbc2d454928ab25c4a38b0724b44f1fd6c1a4b84c895ba8af21b6"
  }
]

追加Fixture · missing-stance

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 1,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 1,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 1,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 1,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: 37841c82e21f585bceb87494546ec6fa34622b5419694775f2efb2a13d244ca8

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "missing-stance",
    "fingerprint": "37841c82e21f585bceb87494546ec6fa34622b5419694775f2efb2a13d244ca8",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "59a8ba59943998170644d9bb66ce168e208d9dd92b7aac8630873d1d4c1b8685"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "missing-stance",
    "fingerprint": "37841c82e21f585bceb87494546ec6fa34622b5419694775f2efb2a13d244ca8",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "59a8ba59943998170644d9bb66ce168e208d9dd92b7aac8630873d1d4c1b8685",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "dc9efed2957179e5f50bf2116618e5ee434861b07e99f70e690bc3f598ba31ac"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "AMBIGUOUS_OR_MISSING_STANCE",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "missing-stance",
    "fingerprint": "37841c82e21f585bceb87494546ec6fa34622b5419694775f2efb2a13d244ca8",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "dc9efed2957179e5f50bf2116618e5ee434861b07e99f70e690bc3f598ba31ac",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "0b6897d3ab665eab098602e7a4c9f282d24d693ac9669532e431549d14f51e1d"
  }
]

追加Fixture · shared-dependency

合成実験内の評価

HOLD · 判定範囲：合成Consensusのみ
SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY

外部実行権限：許可なし
実行状態：未実行

INSUFFICIENT_INDEPENDENCE

集計・出典・監査の詳細

集計値（支持・反対・棄権・混在・欠損）

{
  "raw": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "deduplicated": {
    "support": 3,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  },
  "independent": {
    "support": 1,
    "oppose": 0,
    "abstain": 0,
    "mixed": 0,
    "missing": 0,
    "supportShare": 1,
    "majority": true
  }
}

Fixture SHA-256: e697d38a1acdd059ae19f001dde7940d7025983eedcbae1926dca035ecf141f2

固定論理時刻・合成評価の監査

[
  {
    "kind": "FIXTURE_LOADED",
    "reason": "DETERMINISTIC_SYNTHETIC_INPUT",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 0,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "shared-dependency",
    "fingerprint": "e697d38a1acdd059ae19f001dde7940d7025983eedcbae1926dca035ecf141f2",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": null,
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "68652841e91d4d7d75504d9ca04d2ed3c5fc2bebd3ac06ef4838298e26cba43a"
  },
  {
    "kind": "AGGREGATED",
    "reason": "ROOTS_AND_DEPENDENCY_GROUPS_COLLAPSED",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 1,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:01.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "shared-dependency",
    "fingerprint": "e697d38a1acdd059ae19f001dde7940d7025983eedcbae1926dca035ecf141f2",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "68652841e91d4d7d75504d9ca04d2ed3c5fc2bebd3ac06ef4838298e26cba43a",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "0827b276b0d3ef75be9bb1ae9f0d375a71877cc1ae4129715821aa6e1f4ab2bb"
  },
  {
    "kind": "BOUNDARY_ASSESSED",
    "reason": "INSUFFICIENT_INDEPENDENCE",
    "namespace": "consensus_local_research",
    "sequence": 2,
    "at": "2026-01-01T00:00:02.000Z",
    "fixtureId": "shared-dependency",
    "fingerprint": "e697d38a1acdd059ae19f001dde7940d7025983eedcbae1926dca035ecf141f2",
    "policyHash": "4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06",
    "previousHash": "0827b276b0d3ef75be9bb1ae9f0d375a71877cc1ae4129715821aa6e1f4ab2bb",
    "simulatedBoundaryDecision": "HOLD",
    "decisionScope": "SYNTHETIC_CONSENSUS_ONLY",
    "executionAuthorization": {
      "externalExecutionAuthorized": false,
      "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
      "authorizationSource": "NONE",
      "realWorldEffect": "NONE"
    },
    "executionStatus": "NOT_EXECUTED",
    "provenanceVerificationScope": "SYNTHETIC_FIXTURE_ONLY",
    "eventHash": "7c87885135c89fe070040401e804665459cd900543faadd6d754f9725452227e"
  }
]

研究仮説と手法

これは架空の合成データを使った研究例です。実在する人々の意見、実際の世論調査、AIによる実社会での行動を測定したものではありません。

仮説：共通起源から派生した回答を個別に数えると、多数の独立した支持があるように見える可能性がある。固定の合成Fixtureに共通の評価段階を適用し、集計単位による違いを比較します。

同一起源に賛成と反対が混在するとMIXEDです。欠損はMISSINGとし、混在より優先します。棄権だけならABSTAIN、賛成または反対と棄権だけならその立場へまとめます。同じ依存グループに属する起源は、さらに1つへ集約します。

未検証起源は独立支持へ加えずHOLDとします。賛否混在・欠損、または合成独立グループが3未満でもHOLDです。その他は、独立支持の厳密な多数ならALLOW、それ以外（同数を含む）はDENYです。3グループの最低数には棄権も含みます。これはローカル研究上の規則で、安全性の保証ではありません。

わかっている限界

合成実験は、現実社会での実証ではありません。
実社会の世論調査や、独立した人間の投票・支持を測定していません。
起源は実在人物ではなく、出典の検証は真実性や実社会での独立性の証明ではありません。
ALLOWは観測上の評価です。実行権限・研究者認可・Kosuke Protocolの実判定ではありません。
監査ハッシュは再計算可能な整合性情報です。独立した署名や耐改ざん保管を意味しません。
独立した人間による研究検証や、実証的なエージェント安全性を主張しません。

再現方法と出典

既存の固定Fixtureと集計関数から、通信せずに静的HTML・CSS・JSONを生成します。モデルは実行しません。乱数や実社会のデータを使わず、同じ設定なら同じ成果物になります。

npm test
npm run public-demo:typecheck
npm run public-demo:build

合成スナップショットJSON · 成果物マニフェスト

研究基準コミット: 2df80a8bf46677ce1e00c328c13e72312032707b
ポリシーSHA-256: 4ae976b44218c0220e8dca6dc3ea7f398666a3d654b2264b3501d08075185e06